Saturday, January 03, 2009

How About Some Entertainment Weekly Accountability!

Back in April EW had a horribly unfair teaser on the front cover (pictured in my post here). The headline of the cover blurb was "Oscars '09: The Buzz Has Begun Already."

Without looking inside the magazine, I predicted what buzz they would be predicting...naming 10 films/actors (Revolutionary Road, the Cast of Doubt, Angelina Jolie/The Changeling, Australia, Kate Winslett double nominations, Heath Ledger, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, Frank Langella in Frost/Nixon, Wall-E, Jamie Foxx/The Soloist).

Off all my buzz points, I think I did pretty good, with the exception of the movie The Soloist being moved to 2009.

Entertainment Weekly greatly disappointed me because because the article was so short (pictured left). I was frustrated back in April namely because there article was so short and hardly deserved the cover space on the issue. My post is here comparing our predicted buzz.

In the April article, EW only listed 7 movies/performances. Let me list them in brief here: Australia, Revolutionary Road, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, Keira Knightly/The Duchess, Julianne Moore/Mark Ruffalo/Blindness, Russell Crowe/Leonardo di Caprio/Body of Lies, Viggo Mortesen/The Road.

I have to say 1st, that I am still disappointed in the length of the April 2008 Entertainment Weekly article, especially because it received a cover tease, but I also am reflecting on this because today I received by Entertainment Weekly with EW's Oscar predictions and for-your-considerations and EW's predictions really seem to line up far better with my April buzz, then there buzz.

The Road was postponed, and Body of Lies, Blindness, and The Duchess will probably not receive a single nomination unless it's a random technical nomination...but hardly note worthy.

Sorry Entertainment Weekly, but I have to say, I think you should be ashamed of your April buzz column.

(the second picture shows Dave Karger of EW's current predictions for best pic nods: Benjamin Button, The Dark Knight, Frost/Nixon, Milk, and Slumdog Millionaire)


amy said...

I think it just shows that they need to hire you to write for them!

RC said...

@amy - I'd write for Entertainment Weekly...unfortunatly they haven't asked yet...oh well.